The next time you take a date to the movies you may want to consider opting for an extra large popcorn, or else risk getting walked out on -- or worse, eaten! This may seem like a ludicrously unlikely scenario from a human perspective, but a male spider of the Pisauridae family would not be laughing. Research conducted at the Institute of Botany & Zoology in Masaryk University in the Czech Republic and the Department of Ecology & Genetics in Aarhus University in Denmark has delved into the courtship behavior of spiders of the family/genus Pisaura mirabilis (
see cite 1). The research focused on the conditions that determine whether a female spider will mate or not. When presented with an offering of an egg sac, unwrapped fly, or a wrapped fly, the female's behavioral response was observed. It was hypothesized that the female's preoccupation with the egg sac may distract her into mating. It was opposingly proposed that the female may focus her attention on eating while mating takes place.
The experiment involved the pairing of each male spider in the study with one of three food offerings: an egg sac, an unwrapped fly, and a wrapped fly. Male spiders were then paired with female spiders, and presented their offerings. The condition of the females fell into four different categories: starved or well fed, and lacking in mating experience or experienced. Male spiders with one of the three varieties of offerings were paired with each of the four varieties of females. The investigators found that the majority of females showed no preference for food type. It would appear that motherly care on behalf of the female plays little role in her decision to eat the egg sac. The female’s desire to eat did play a role in her behavior, as starved females stole or accepted the food more quickly than fed females.
What of the instances when females are compelled to devour males? Bilde and his co-investigators concluded that as a result of females eating males during mating attempts, male food giving is selected for. The researchers further reference
Randy Thornhill, who incorporating Trivers, states:
“ ..It is the relative parental investment of the sexes in their offspring that controls the operation of sexual selection. In most species a female’s investment per offspring greatly exceeds that of the male” (Thornhill 1976 on Trivers 1972).
In light of this hypothesis, it would seem appropriate that male behavior would change given the desire of the females to eat. Males that did not offer food were selected against and likely eaten, while males that offered a meal and distracted the female were more likely to be spared during mating (and thereby able to spread their “giving” genes) (Bilde). The take home message is that, along with protection, it would behoove all of us to bring an extra candy bar along …just in case.
Buabbud6 and defuria6 both included that the act of the female eating the male is not restricted to this species of spider (or only spiders for that matter). Defuria6 brought up the example of the praying mantis, a non-spider species which often exhibits eating of the male during mating. Buabbud6 offered a profound statement, "what hurts more to a spider, rejection, or death?". Across these species it seems that some "risks" are taken on behalf of the male in order to obtain mating attempts. Some of the evidence would suggest that mating is important enough to risk one's life. Additionally, the low occurance of male killing (in the spider) may be outwieghed by the advantages of mating and spreading ones genes (Blide and co-authors). Chances are that a male will not be killed during a mating attempt. Thus, it is probably in the male's favor to take the risk.
Alvarez6 asked," is there another way for the male to avoid being eaten or left behind?". Discussed in the
article is the concept of thanatosis (faking death). The male, when presenting the food offering, will sometimes "fake" being dead in order to avoid provoking the female. This tactic may result in the survival of many males who would otherwise be noticed and eaten.
Posted by AKE(2)
(cite 1.) Trine Bilde, Christina Tuni, Rehab Elsayed, Stano Pekar, Soren Toft
Institute of Botany & Zoology, Masaryk University, Czech Republic
Department of Ecology & Genetics, Aarhus University Denmark
Animal Behaviour, Volume 73, Issue 2, February 2007, pages 267-273: Nuptial gifts of male spiders: sensory exploitation of the female's maternal care instinct or foraging motivation?
Randy Thornhill
The American Naturalist, Volume 110, No. 974, Juy- August 1976: Sexual Selection and Nuptial Feeding Behavior in Bittacus Apicalis (Insecta: Mecoptera)